Proof that iTunes’ Podcast Recommendations Are Meaningless

So, if you know me or follow either of my podcasts, you know that I do a fantasy football podcast called Extra Points. My good friend Scott and I have done it for two full years (entering our third season), before any of the major FF sites were doing podcasts. We’ve got a decent sized audience and we’ve actually won a Podcast Peer Award for best sports podcast back in ‘06. I know we’ve got a good show. So, naturally, I was hopeful, when I saw that iTunes decided to feature fantasy football podcasts, that we’d be featured. No dice. Oh, well, that’s the way things go, no biggie.

Or, it was no biggie until I saw who they did decide to feature:

Featured Fantasy Football Podcast at iTunes

Now, I’m not going to knock anyone else’s podcast. That’s not my style. And, to be honest, I don’t listen to any other FF podcasts because I’ve OD’ed on information by the time I release my show. But one particular show really surprised me, mostly because it only has two episodes, neither of which has anything to do with fantasy football:

The Fantasy Football Podcast - With No Episodes

Now, again, nothing against the people who did this podcast; there’s no shame in podfading, and it’s not their fault that they’re still listed. But wouldn’t you think that someone at Apple would, I don’t know, go through their recommendations before they posted them and make sure they’re actually relevant? Basically, what you say to me with this choice are two things. One, you don’t give a damn about who you feature and just picked thirteen podcasts that had the words “fantasy football” in their titles without even looking at the podcasts in question. And two, my podcast (and every other fantasy football podcast that wasn’t featured) is apparently less worthy than a show that has no episodes. Plus, you invalidate all the other recommendations in the process, since you’ve just killed your credibility by deciding to feature a dead podcast. Those other podcasts could be great (and I’m not saying they’re not), but how can I trust any of those recommendations now?

Great job, Apple. Way to be a responsible and influential partner in promoting podcasting. I’ll stick to Google from now on.

I Could Be a Video Game Stock Analyst

Seriously, I’m in the wrong profession. I can make educated guesses with the best of them, especially when there’s no accountability for being wrong. I mean, really, look at this quote today from a Wedbush Morgan analyst:

“It is possible that Sony’s cost of production for the PS3 has declined to the point that the company may consider a hardware price cut some time this summer, and we may see a price cut for the PS2 before the holidays.”

Seriously, could you have any less conviction? Sure, it’s possible that their production costs have dropped significantly. It’s also possible that I’m actually an astronaut and I’m going to the International Space Station tomorrow. I’m not, but hey, it’s possible, right?

I mean, really, these guys come up with guesses (let’s not glorify it by calling it analysis) based on reading the same gaming blogs that you and I read, and they get paid for it. I could come up with a rationale for why the PS3 could or could not get a price cut this summer, and it would probably have a lot more behind it than that. (My opinion is that we won’t see one this summer, especially now that MS has come out with the Xbox 360 Elite; if price was that much of an issue, they wouldn’t have discontinued the 20 GB model.) So why are they paying these guys big bucks to come up with opinions that are either obvious or crack-headed?

This is why I don’t play the stock market, by the way. Because these are the same guys who determine if I make or lose money on a daily basis, and that scares the hell out of me…

Wicked Good Podcast #54: Why Didn’t I Bring My Eighteen-Wheeler?

Listen now or subscribe to the podcast feed!

This week, ScottJ joins us yet again, Gloomy Gus the vampiric phlebotomist, gender confusion at the hospital restrooms, more drama at Babies ‘R’ Us, Supermarket Sweep comes to life, Faux Foodcast, The Swipe, Cake Mania, and Patriot’s Day.

Music:
“Other Worlds” by Casey Desmond, courtesy of the Podsafe Music Network
Intro Music: “Pocketbook” by Derek K Miller
Outro Music: “Remember Hope” by Farewell Redemption

Links:
Couplecasts.com
Our Blog at Loopipes.com

Podcasts Mentioned:
Love Long and Prosper
Mostly News
Phedippidations
All Axis Radio: Canada
Geek Acres
Tucker Tales
Redboy Podcast
Barely Podcasting

Technorati Tags:

Feedback: Feel free to e-mail us at WickedGoodPodcast|at|gmail.com or call us at 206-600-MASS(6277)!

A Charter For Irritation

FIOS can’t get here soon enough so I can drop Charter Cable like a bad habit.

It was bad enough that they dropped NFL Network one day, randomly, and never got it back. (Granted, that’s not entirely their fault because NFL Network’s terms were borderline unreasonable, but there are still plenty of cable companies who carry NFL Network with no issue, and Charter isn’t one of them.) It got worse when it took a freaking week to get my HD working after it was installed because the rep who set it up forgot to enable the HD service on my account and none of the five CSRs who I called were able to see that and turn it on. But now, just a couple of weeks after jacking up our rates, they’re dropping Versus, a week before the NHL playoffs, mind you, which is pretty much the only way I can see Devils games without paying highway robbery prices for Center Ice or attempting to watch the grainy replays on Google Video a week later.

I don’t even have anything witty to say. I’m just generally annoyed that Charter can continually increase what I pay while reducing the service I get, for no discernable reason.

Wicked Good Podcast #52: Baby Jewelry on Layaway

Listen now or subscribe to the podcast feed!

This week, leave Maureen’s Irish twins alone, the breast seminar ever, the full retelling of the Babies ‘R’ Us registry fiasco, accosted co-workers at the Butcherie, Puzzle Quest is digital crack, and a triumphant return to the flea market.

Music:
“Little Pieces” by Uncle Seth, courtesy of the Podsafe Music Network
Intro Music: “Pocketbook” by Derek K Miller
Outro Music: “Remember Hope” by Farewell Redemption

Links:
Our New Blog at Loopipes.com
Puzzle Quest Demohttp://www.gamedaily.com/canvases/gd/_a/download-puzzle-quest-demo/20070315101009990002

Podcasts Mentioned:
Love Long and Prosper
Mostly News
Life on Tap
Tucker Tales
Shelly’s Podcast

Technorati Tags:

Feedback: Feel free to e-mail us at WickedGoodPodcast|at|gmail.com or call us at 206-600-MASS(6277)!

Babies ‘R’ Us, Except When They’re Not

So we’ve had a registry with Babies ‘R’ Us set up for a couple of months now; we set it up when my parents came up for Martin Luther King Weekend, as they do every year. On said registry, we had a number of items, not the least of which were a car seat, stroller, and Pack ‘n’ Play, all by Graco, all selected by Maureen in a pattern called Windsor. It was actually quite the nice pattern.

What’s that, you say? I should be referring to it in the present tense? We’re getting to that.

So we attended a breast feeding seminar at the local BRU (an experience we may discuss in further detail on the next episode of The Wicked Good Podcast), and afterward went to check on the status of the above mentioned items. You see, Maureen, being the diligent mom to be that she is, has been keeping up with the items on our registry, and she noticed (thanks to some prompting from Scott J) that the Windsor items have been marked as “Temporarily Out Of Stock” on the BRU web site. We go up and down the aisles and can’t find anything in Windsor. So I suggest that we go to customer service and get to the bottom of things.

At customer service, we’re informed that the Windsor line has been discontinued. We ask if any of the stores in the area have any left, and, without even a check of the computer, the employee says that all the stores are out and that there are none left. (Apparently, she’s related to one of the characters in Heroes. You know, the one who can read everything online with her mind.)

Needless to say, we’re upset. (OK, Maureen more than me, but that’s to be expected.) There are actually several things wrong with this scenario. One, you’re in a store where you’re dealing with pregnant, borderline crazy women all day; you’d think that the employees would have some sensitivity and not treat the fact that the car seat that we’d registered for as discontinued as though they stopped making our current brand of motor oil. Just some compassion would be nice, as opposed to a flippant, “Nope!” when we ask if anyone in the area has these items.

Two, where was the notification? Their system knows that we registered for these things. Is it so difficult to send out an e-mail to let us know that these things are discontinued? When were they planning on letting us know that we couldn’t buy the item that we’d registered for? We’re talking about necessary items here; it would’ve been nice to know that we’d need to pick something else out, you know, sometime before the baby’s born.

Finally, remember the Heroes reject who told us that all the stores were out? Turns out that wasn’t the case. We called another BRU, and the first one we called had the stroller and car seat, so that’s on hold for us to pick up tomorrow. The pack and play was a little harder to find, but it seems that Maureen was able to find one near her parents in California, so, for the time being, crisis averted.

I’m extremely disappointed with Babies ‘R’ Us. They really could have handled this situation a LOT differently and ended up with some happy, loyal customers. Instead, they took the lazy route in almost every instance (with the exception of Roger at the Framingham, MA store and Victoria at the Warwick, RI store who, even at closing time, did their best to track down as much as they could for us,), and we ended up a lot more upset and annoyed than we should have been, honestly. Five minutes extra looking stuff up at the store that we were at instead of getting us out the door as quickly as possible so they could continue their conversation could have avoided an extremely unpleasant evening.

Oh, and they owe me a Quizno’s sandwich. Roast Beef on Garlic Bread. Because that’s where we should have gone after we left the store, instead of going home to search for the juvenile Holy Grail.

UPDATE: The registry fiasco gets more egregious. Maureen called Graco and discovered that, yes, the style is officially discontinued, and, to make matters worse, it’s a Toys/Babies ‘R’ Us exclusive style. There’s absolutely no excuse for the lack of notification from BRU, especially since my mother was able to add these items to a test registry this morning.

That said, Maureen’s been calling around to a bunch of stores, and everyone she’s gotten on the phone has done their best to help us out. So thumbs up to the people answering the phones at BRU, but two thumbs down to their registry service.

My Own Personal March Madness

CBS is on my list. And it’s not a list you generally want to be on.

After a long session last night of recording Wicked Good Podcast #50 (hooray!), Maureen and I decided to watch the newest episode of The Amazing Race before turning in for the night. Now, I know darned well that the NCAA tournament is going on; I’ve filled out my bracket based on which mascot/logo I like better, because I know zero about college sports in general, and college basketball in particular. I’m a big sports fan, sure, but if they stopped playing college basketball tomorrow, I’d never know the difference.

What does March Madness have to do with The Amazing Race, you may ask? Well, CBS broadcasts the games, and the games apparently ran late. Since CBS has zero slack built into their Sunday schedule, The Amazing Race came on 45 minutes late. Which means, since TiVo wasn’t informed, we got to see 45 minutes of 60 Minutes and the first 15 minutes of The Amazing Race. I think Maureen was able to back up and catch the ending to at least see who won; I had completely given up on watching the episode at this point.

Honestly, I know CBS probably doesn’t care much about DVR viewers because we don’t watch all of their commercials, but isn’t there some way to change the schedule around so that this doesn’t happen? Like, don’t show one of your shows that night and then have a post game show scheduled to run until 8; that’s what Fox does when it has the late football game or NASCAR or whatever. Then, at the most, it runs maybe five minutes late.

And yeah, I know I can tell TiVo to run late, but I really shouldn’t have to waste an extra hour on my TiVo because CBS can’t get their schedule right. I’m sure this has to annoy non-Tivo viewers too, doesn’t it? I mean, there’s got to be someone who unexpectedly has to choose between the second half of Amazing Race and Family Guy or Desperate Housewives, isn’t there? You’d figure that CBS would lose at least a percentage of those viewers.

I just figure there’s got to be a solution to this problem that CBS could come up with. I tolerated this during football season because I follow all the games and know when CBS is likely to run late. But I shouldn’t have to have my Tivo account for every random sporting event that CBS may decide to run, even if it’s something major like March Madness. They’re the ones who want me to watch their programming (especially now that Nielsen’s working on including DVR numbers in their ratings); they shouldn’t make it harder for me to see what I want to see.

No Unified Wii Friends List Confirmed

So Eurogamer’s confirmed with Nintendo UK yesterday’s report that there will be no unified friends list on the Wii, which I’m still having trouble coming to grips with.

We asked Nintendo UK whether we were missing something; whether there was some obvious reason for going down this route rather than adopting the unified approach that has become a console gaming standard, but were simply told, “Nintendo has taken this step as we believe it’s the right thing to do.”

C’mon, that’s the best explanation you can give? That’s the tech equivalent of, “Eat your broccoli because it’s good for you.” Which I don’t, because that’s not a good enough reason to force something down my throat that I can’t stand.

That’s great that Nintendo thinks it’s the right thing to do, but that statement needs further explanation. Is there something wrong with having one convenient friends list that covers all games as opposed to having to look individual people up in-game? Given that their opinion seems to vastly differ from that of all of their customers, they have some ’splainin’ to do in order to get their customers (and customers to be; remember, not everyone who wants a Wii can get one yet, and some could still change their minds) on board with this and accept that it is actually a good thing.

The Fine Line Between Promotion and Spam

CC Chapman had a great post on Managing the Gray today about personalization in self-promotion, and it got me thinking about something that got me kind of annoyed last night.

Some setup: Maureen and I have been on Myspace since we started The Wicked Good Podcast. We thought we’d use it to promote the show, and that hasn’t really happened as much as we thought it would (though we have found some great local bands to play on the show as a result), mainly because I don’t have the patience to reformat our show notes into MySpace’s craptastic interface. We added a number of people at first, but since then, we’re more or less let people come to us, and as long as said request isn’t from someone trying to get us to sign up for free iPods or adult services, we’ll happily accept any request.

What I’ve noticed lately, though, is the proliferation of event invitations on MySpace. These differ from bulletins in that they generate an e-mail to all the invitees. This is fine when used properly, but they’re often used to spam everyone’s friend list with some sort of announcement. In particular, what sent me over the edge was some podcaster who apparently added me to their friend list a while back sent out an event invitation to, I presume, his entire friend list to announce that he had posted episode #10 of his or her podcast. Said podcaster is no longer on my friend list.

Now, this could be the best podcast ever created, but I’m already sour on it, and the event invitation had the exact opposite effect of what this podcaster intended. Now, if this person had taken the time to send me a personal message (preferably indicating that they’d at least heard of my show), I’d probably give his show a listen, even if it’s not my thing. I’ll go way out of my way for my listeners. But I get so much spam lately that all I’m looking for is ways to reduce it, so anyone who’s bombing me with unsolicited e-mail on MySpace is going to be taken off my friend list as a defensive measure, and I’m sure I’m not alone in this line of thinking.

I think all the social networking opportunities that are available on the internet now are creating a Pokemon-esque “gotta catch ‘em all” mentality, and a lot of folks are so consumed with building said networks that they don’t give much thought to how to use them effectively. It’s really easy to send out a mass message to everyone in your network and hope that it sticks with a couple of people. But keep in mind that you’re not the only one who’s building these gigantic, loosely-associated networks (especially on MySpace, where “friend” is used in only the loosest of senses; I probably couldn’t tell you who half of my MySpace friends are without looking at their profiles), and that you’ll probably alienate twice as many people as you bring in. You’re much better off using these social networking sites to create personal connections with people and bring them in that way. It doesn’t have the instant gratification of a blast, but it’ll pay off better in the long run.

Social networking can be really powerful mojo, and as a wise man once said: With great power comes great responsibility.

How Quickly Wii Forget…

So the latest buzz around the video game blogs (or at least Wii Fanboy) is that the new Harry Potter game for the Wii will have a microphone accessory included, presumably to allow the player to verbally perform the incantations for the spells that Harry and company perform. People are apparently getting really excited. I believe that this is because these people have never attempted to play a game that requires speech recognition.

Pretty much every time I’ve played a game that involves more than picking up a tune (as in the Karaoke Revolution games) or blowing into it (see half of the Nintendo DS catalog), it’s been an exercise in abject frustration. We gave up on Nintendogs after a day because the dog couldn’t recognize its own name. Odama is gathering dust because I would go hoarse screaming, “Press forward!” only to have my soldiers sit there and get trampled. Heck, even Brain Age, which only has to recognize four freaking words (red, blue, yellow and black) can’t get it right. It’s always entertaining seeing someone attempting to play Brain Age and shouting, “Blue!” into it repeatedly, each utterance more frustrated than the last, until they start to devolve into some sort of mental case. I’m amazed that we haven’t heard about as many Brain-Age related DS breakages as we have Wii Sports related television breakages. So we can’t handle “blue” but we’ll be able to interpret “Wingardium Leviosa”? That’s some heavy duty magic they’re working there, then; I hope they’ve got Dumbledore on the case.

Add to that we’re talking about EA, who has been extremely hit or miss in terms of Wii development. Plus, it’s a licensed game, which is strike 2, and to make matters worse, it’s a Harry Potter game, all of which have been boring at best and a complete waste of time at worst. So what is there to get excited about again?

Maybe I’m jaded after 20+ years of gaming, but I’m reaching the point with some of this stuff where I’m not going to believe it until I see it. Nintendo I trust to wow me with doing fun stuff with the Wii and making it work (other than online gaming, of course). EA, not so much…